
Maybe it was a mistake at the self-checkout. Maybe it was a bad decision on a bad day. Maybe you did not do it at all.
Either way, you ended up in a back office with a loss prevention officer. Then the police arrived. Now you have a piece of paper with a court date on it, and a knot in your stomach that will not go away.
You might be telling yourself it is minor. The item was cheap. It is a first offence. It will probably just go away.
It might. But a theft charge is a criminal charge. If it ends in a conviction, it creates a criminal record. That record can follow you into job interviews, border crossings, and immigration applications for years.
In this post, you will learn what a theft under $5,000 charge means, what happens next, how these charges can be resolved without a record, and what to avoid doing right now.
What does a theft under $5,000 charge actually mean?
Theft is an offence under section 334 of the Criminal Code of Canada. When the value involved is $5,000 or less, it is called theft under $5,000.
That covers a wide range of situations:
- Shoplifting from a store, including self-checkout errors that police treat as intentional.
- Taking something from an employer.
- Keeping property that was not yours after being asked to return it.
Theft under $5,000 is a hybrid offence. The Crown prosecutor decides whether to proceed by summary conviction, which is the less serious route, or by indictment. For most first-time charges, the Crown proceeds summarily.
Less serious is relative. A summary conviction is still a criminal conviction.
Why is a “minor” theft charge such a big deal?
Because the fine, if there is one, is not what hurts. The record is.
A theft conviction can affect:
- Employment. Many employers run police record checks. Theft raises red flags for jobs involving cash, inventory, or trust.
- Vulnerable sector checks. Jobs and volunteer roles with children, seniors, or healthcare can be affected.
- Travel to the United States. U.S. border officers can treat theft as a serious offence for entry purposes.
- A conviction can lead to being refused entry, and you may need a waiver to travel.Immigration status. If you are not a Canadian citizen, a theft conviction can seriously affect permanent residence, work permits, and citizenship applications.
- Professional licences. Some regulated professions ask about criminal convictions.
A criminal record does not fade on its own. Removing it later through a record suspension means waiting years and completing an application process.
What happens after you’re charged?
The process usually follows a set path.
- Release. Most people charged with theft under $5,000 are released at the scene or at the station with paperwork that tells them when to go to court.
- Fingerprints and photos. Your paperwork may require you to attend for fingerprinting. Do not skip it. Failing to attend is a separate criminal offence.
- First appearance. This is not a trial. It is where the process starts and where disclosure is usually provided.
- Disclosure. This is the Crown’s evidence against you. It can include store video, loss prevention notes, and police statements.
- Resolution or trial. After disclosure is reviewed, the case is either resolved or set down for trial.
Having someone represent you from the first appearance can save you time off work and help you avoid early mistakes. You can learn more about what happens in the courtroom on our resources page.

Is there a way to resolve this without a criminal record?
Often, yes. This is the most important thing to understand about a first theft charge.
Depending on the facts and the courthouse, possible outcomes can include:
- Withdrawal. The Crown may withdraw the charge if the evidence is weak or was gathered improperly.
- Diversion. Some first-time offenders qualify for diversion programs. You complete certain conditions, such as a donation or community service hours, and the charge is withdrawn.
- Peace bond. In some cases, the charge is withdrawn in exchange for your agreement to keep the peace and follow conditions for a period of time. A peace bond is not a criminal conviction.
- Discharge. If you plead or are found guilty, the court may grant an absolute or conditional discharge. You are not convicted, and the record of the discharge is removed from the national police database after a set period.
- Acquittal at trial. If the Crown cannot prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt, you are found not guilty.
Which of these is realistic depends on your evidence, your history, and the Crown’s position. That is exactly why reviewing disclosure before making any decision matters.

What should you avoid doing right now?
A few common mistakes can make your situation harder.
- Do not talk about the incident. Not to the store, not to police without advice, and not to friends by text.
- Do not post about it. Social media posts can end up in disclosure.
- Do not contact the store to apologize or explain. It can be treated as an admission.
- Do not pay a civil demand letter without advice. Some stores send a separate demand for money through their lawyers. That is a civil matter, not part of your criminal case. Paying it does not make the criminal charge go away.
- Do not miss fingerprinting or court dates. Either one can lead to new charges.
- Do not plead guilty at your first appearance just to get it over with. That choice creates a record.
Can XPolice defend a theft charge?
In most cases, yes. Licensed paralegals in Ontario are permitted to defend certain criminal charges when the Crown proceeds by summary conviction. Theft under $5,000 is one of them. That covers the large majority of first-time theft charges.
If the Crown decides to proceed by indictment, a lawyer must take the case. If that happens, we will tell you right away and make sure you are connected with the right counsel. You will never be left guessing about who can represent you.
You can see the full list of criminal charges we defend on our website.
How XPolice can help
Our team combines licensed paralegals with former police officers who understand how theft investigations are built. We know what loss prevention reports look like, how store video is handled, and where these cases tend to have weak spots.
When you call us about theft charges, we will:
- Explain the charge and what is at stake.
- Appear for you at court dates where your attendance is not required.
- Request and review disclosure.
- Pursue withdrawal, diversion, or another outcome that avoids a criminal record wherever possible.
The bottom line
A theft under $5,000 charge can feel small. The record it can create is not.
- Theft under $5,000 is a criminal charge, even when the value is low.
- A conviction can affect jobs, travel, and immigration for years.
- Many first-time charges can be resolved without a criminal record.
We tell every driver to Call Before You Pay. With a criminal charge, the same rule means call before you plead. Book a free consultation or reach XPolice at 1-888-XPOLICE (1-888-976-5423).
Frequently asked questions
Will I get a criminal record for shoplifting in Ontario?
Only if you are convicted. Many first-time charges are resolved through withdrawal, diversion, a peace bond, or a discharge. None of these is a criminal conviction.
Do I have to go to court for a theft under $5,000 charge?
Not always in person. A representative can often appear for you on routine court dates. Some appearances, such as a plea or a trial, may require you to attend.
Can a paralegal represent me on a theft charge?
Yes, when the Crown proceeds by summary conviction, which is the usual route for first-time theft under $5,000. If the Crown proceeds by indictment, a lawyer is required.